Shelton, Connecticut

Pizza in Shelton, ranked

Kev has reviewed 9 pizza spots in Shelton, CT, each scored out of 10 after a real visit. The average score is 7.4. Top pick: Addeo's Fire and Ice at 8/10. Latest review: Fire Engine Pizza Co (Shelton) on Sep 11, 2026.

1. 1Addeo's Fire and IceBrick Oven / Wood Fired · reviewed Jun 28, 20268/10
2. 2Captain's PizzaClassic / Other · reviewed Jul 21, 20268/10
3. 3Fire Engine Pizza Co (Shelton)Classic / Other · reviewed Sep 11, 20268/10
4. 4Planet PizzaClassic / Other · reviewed Sep 3, 20267.5/10
5. 5Matto Wine BarClassic / Other · reviewed Aug 20, 20267.4/10
6. 6Pier 131Classic / Other · reviewed Jul 19, 20267/10
7. 7DJs PizzaClassic / Other · reviewed Sep 10, 20267/10
8. 8MercatoClassic / Other · reviewed Jul 16, 20266.9/10
9. 9Artan's PizzaClassic / Other · reviewed Jul 26, 20266.7/10

Watch the full video reviews on TikTok @kevgotheat, or suggest the next Shelton spot for Kev to try.

See all 119 reviews on the Master List →